Teachable Stopped Building Community. The Platform Eating That Market Was Built by Teachable's Own People.
Teachable has paused investment in its community feature. The company most creators bolt on instead was founded by ex-Teachable staff and backed by Teachable's founder.
Teachable's help center now carries a line that reads like a white flag. The company says it decided to "pause investment in the Community feature so we can focus on improving the overall learning experience" inside Teachable. Existing communities keep working, and Teachable says it will maintain uptime and "keep the lights on." Nothing new gets built.
The reasoning is blunt.Teachable says most discussion and engagement happens in and around course content rather than standalone community spaces, so it is putting its money into courses and the student hub instead.
Which leaves a hole. And the company best positioned to fill it was built by Teachable's own alumni.
Three ex-employees saw the gap from the inside
Circle was co-founded by Sid Yadav, former VP of Product at Teachable, along with Rudy Santino and Andrew Guttormsen, Teachable's former VP of Growth and Marketing. Yadav had started at Teachable in 2014 as its first designer and front-end engineer. Circle launched publicly in August 2020 after eight months in beta, with early testers including Pat Flynn and Anne-Laure Le Cunff.
It began as a moonlight project.Yadav and Santino built a first version in about a month and invited creators they already knew from their jobs at Teachable to try it.
By Mighty Networks' account of the period, the Teachable employees saw the course platform was missing a community feature and built Circle as an add-on, with the explicit vision of integrating with Teachable and adding communities to Teachable courses — before adding its own course tools and pulling away from Teachable integrations to stand alone.
Then the founder wrote a check
In his own launch essay, Yadav describes a prototype link and a few messages to "my former boss and one of our first investors, Ankur Nagpal" — Teachable's founder — which turned into a commitment to invest.
Circle's $1.5 million pre-seed in August 2020 was led by Notation Capital, with participation from Nagpal, Dave Ambrose and Matthew Ziskie. The size of that bet, per the episode notes for The Peel podcast, was extraordinary:the show's chapter list states that Teachable CEO Ankur Nagpal invested 90% of his liquid net worth in Circle's pre-seed round (listed there at $1.7m).
It worked out.Circle has raised $33M, took a Tiger Global-led Series A at a $200M valuation, is profitable, and has crossed $50 million in ARR with 280 people and customers including Jay Shetty, Tim Ferriss and Ali Abdaal.
Eventually the course platform became the customer."We never expected a customer like Teachable to emerge," Yadav told Smart Passive Income, adding that it wasn't who Circle was building for early on.
Why your stack has two bills
This is the practical part.A Teachable creator who wants a real community signs up for a third-party tool and pays an extra monthly subscription on top of the Teachable fee. Circle's Professional plan runs $89/month billed annually, Business $199/month. Teachable's own paid plans range from $59 to $299 a month billed annually.
Teachable's suggestion for creators who still want engagement: course comments.
Sources
- Create and manage community — Teachable Help Center
- Circle (software) — Wikipedia
- It Takes a Community: The Story behind Circle — Sid Yadav / Medium
- Content & Community: Building Business With Sid Yadav at Circle — Open Source CEO
- Immigrant to $250M CEO: How Circle Powers the Creator Economy — The Peel with Turner Novak
- Raising $5.5M to Build the Community Platform for Creators — Failory
- Skool vs Circle: Which is Best for Community? — Mighty Networks
- How Creators Can Build a Thriving Online Community with Circle.so — Smart Passive Income
- Can You Create an Online Community With Teachable? — Heights Platform
- Circle: What Five Years of Running My Entire Business On It Has Taught Me — Convology
- Circle vs Teachable — Learniverse
Editor’s note: The best inside-baseball plot in the industry, and it explains a line item on every creator's credit card statement.
Keep reading
His Finance Textbooks Turned Up in a Pirate Library. Now He's Arguing AI Will Erase the Market for Teaching Materials.
A Boston College professor is one of six textbook authors suing OpenAI and Microsoft — and their market-harm theory is every knowledge seller's nightmare.
They Built a Business Teaching Creators. Last Week They Wrote a $25,000 Check to One With 670 Subscribers.
Colin and Samir spent a decade selling knowledge to 1.6 million people. Now they're funding the people who bought it.
Mosseri Says the Servers "Add Up." Instagram's Free AI Now Comes With a Meter.
The head of Instagram said Meta must "either throttle people or ask them to pay." For creators filming course promos in-app, the throttle came first.
He Dunked His Face in Saratoga Water and Broke the Internet. The Real Money Was a $3,300 Course.
Forbes put Ashton Hall at No. 41 on its 2026 Top Creators list with $10 million. The punchline is buried in one sentence.
